A new Edpuzzle feature that claims to detect unusual activity flagged several seniors’ Edpuzzle submissions in a Religious Studies class, resulting in JUGs and zeros on the assignment for those students.
Students and their teacher came away with different understandings of what the feature tracks and what a flag proves, raising questions about how Brophy uses detection tools in class.
Before starting an Edpuzzle assignment, if the detector is active, students are notified with a warning: “Keep in mind, we’ll notify your teacher if we detect unusual activity during your assignment.”
According to Mrs. Agliano, Edpuzzle does not show a recording of what the student did, “just the flag.”
The teacher dashboard shows a flag on the question if the student copy/pasted, right-clicked, or highlighted within the page.
Mrs. Agliano said she turned on the feature because it was one of Edpuzzle’s many options.
“You know how Edpuzzle has things like not being able to skip or fast-forward? Edpuzzle just put in a new level of engagement where it discourages copying and pasting, just to help ensure that students are answering the questions they’re asked,” Mrs. Agliano said.
“At its core, it’s supposed to deter copying and pasting answers,” Mrs. Agliano said.
A teacher would be inclined to use this feature as a way to discourage not only copy and paste, but, on a more serious level, plagiarism.
She said students who told her they did something different were flagged the same way as everyone else. “Based on what I had in front of me, I couldn’t distinguish,” Mrs. Agliano said.
From Mrs. Agliano’s perspective, this was not an academic integrity issue, but rather not doing the assignment the way she assigned it.
Mrs. Agliano compared the situation to a paper assignment. “If I gave you a worksheet and a reading, and you Googled all the answers, and then I watched you Google all the answers, I would say, ‘Hey, you’re not doing the worksheet like I’m asking you to do it.’ So that’s a class conduct problem,” Mrs. Agliano said.
Dr. Brian Johnson said that when an issue regarding AI or cheating is brought to him, he looks at the assignment first.
“What are the instructions from the teacher? How was this given and presented to your students? What were their expectations? Then, in the event that those expectations are not met, or that things fall outside of the parameters of the assignment, that’s when it warrants more disciplinary action,” Dr. Johnson said.
“If you incorporate technology, the same rules are at play,” Dr. Johnson said.
Students flagged were asked to stay after class to hear the explanation from Mrs. Agliano about this penalty.
A student Beau, whose last name has been removed to protect his digital privacy, was one of the students who stayed after. The program showed that Beau highlighted and copied a question within the assignment.
“I don’t physically recall doing that,” Beau said. “It was on a question that was based on a character in the video. So there’s no real reason that I would have tried to copy and paste the question.”
Another student named, Jack, whose last name has been removed to protect his digital privacy was also flagged by the copy-and-paste detection feature.
Jack believes spellcheck may have caused the flag. “My only possible guess for what could have flagged the system for copying and pasting … was that it’s a spelling error, and when you have it corrected, Edpuzzle flags it as pasting,” Jack said.
The Roundup tested the feature: supervisor Jake Kelly ’09 assigned a Roundup reporter three Edpuzzles. When Edpuzzle’s copy/paste setting is on, students cannot paste text into the assignment, but Grammarly’s spellcheck still works and flags the question for copy/paste.
This is the same spellcheck Jack was referring to.
Right-clicking anywhere on the screen also flagged the question, even when it was not used to highlight or copy and paste. Highlighting also flagged the question.
























